News Analysis: U.S. Treasury's "Kremlin list" mocked as sloppy, meaningless

Source: Xinhua| 2018-02-01 14:46:37|Editor: Chengcheng
Video PlayerClose

WASHINGTON, Jan. 31 (Xinhua) -- The U.S. Treasury Department on Monday published a long-awaited list of Russian officials and business leaders eligible for sanctions for alleged meddling in the U.S. presidential elections.

Experts, however, have questioned the list, saying its content and coverage has threatened its credibility and operability.

The list, aiming at pressuring the Kremlin to cut off its behavior in Ukraine and Crimea, included 114 senior Russian officials and 96 oligarchs, each of whom has an estimated net worth of 1 trillion U.S. dollars.

It came after U.S. President Donald Trump signed a legislation in August last year that requires the Treasury Department to provide a list of names of Russian officials and wealthy oligarchs that have intimate relations with the Kremlin and a sizeable amount of personal wealth.

Russia has responded strongly as President Vladimir Putin said later that the list is an unfriendly gesture and would undermine the nation's relations with the United States in the long run.

The Forbes confirmed on its website that the billionaires list "is copied" from the media outlet's 2017 list of the World's Billionaires.

"The Treasury Department's list is an exact replica of the Russians on the 2017 billionaires list," it noted. "In an emailed statement to Forbes, a Treasury spokesperson explained that the unclassified report was derived from open sources, including Forbes and others."

Media organizations also pointed out the stunning similarity between the Russian officials list and the officials name list on the English website of the Russian federation government.

The report looks just like a Kremlin phone book copied and pasted by U.S. secret services, said Konstantin Kosachyov, chairman of the State Duma international affairs committee.

"In it, one finds the chiefs of all Russian leadership bodies in alphabetical order," Kosachyov said on his Facebook page.

Former U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul described the list as meaningless and sloppy.

"What classified 'intel' was used to compose this list? I see no evidence of that at all," he tweeted, lashing out at the "ridiculously broad and thus meaningless" list.

"Listing whole GOR is a joke," he added.

Dmitri Trenin, Carnegie Moscow Center's director, said on twitter that "the power of U.S. sanctions is not in the specifics of people or companies blacklisted but in a simple message: those who want to do deals with Russians might have to deal with the United States. The recent Kremlin list underlines that message."

"Russians are not to be deterred by U.S. sanctions. They are designed to deter non-Russians from dealing with Russia," he added.

Despite the U.S. statement on Tuesday that Washington has persuaded multiple nations not to do business with Russia to avoid being sanctioned by the United States, Trenin argued that "U.S. blacklists like U.S. sanctions work to make most Russians - elites as well as the public - feel that they are together in this standoff with the United States."

TOP STORIES
EDITOR’S CHOICE
MOST VIEWED
EXPLORE XINHUANET
010020070750000000000000011100001369420201